Here is a paragraph from’s Andrew O’Hehir on the MPAA’s choice to rate the documentary about school bullying “R” and thus limit and restrict access to the kids who already live worse lives than the movie might “expose them” to.  The MPAA is ridiculous on its face.  Any movie you can think of with gratuitous violence that serves ONLY as a pornographic stimulant, ONLY as an end in itself, finds its way to an “approval” of the “PG-13″ crowd.  Any movie with the word “fuck” in it gets an automatic “R.”  I don’t know the ratios of breasts to butts or the number of  “sexual situations” tallied that lead to “R” ratings (or, gasp, NR or NC-17) but I’m sure there’s a kind of utilitarian equation for the morals police.  Recall that The King’s Speech was rated “R” while True Grit was “PG-13.”

Over and over again in “Bully,” we see adults who feel bureaucratically paralyzed, who look the other way, who are unwilling to make judgments between perpetrators and victims, or who actively condone vicious and sadistic behavior as the Darwinian natural order of childhood. In many cases you can feel considerable sympathy for these people….Declaring that underage kids can’t even see this film without a grown-up to hold their hands, however, falls somewhere near the nastier end of that spectrum of indecision. With the stated goal of not offending anybody, the MPAA has essentially told the bullied teens in the movie and outside it — gay and lesbian kids, autistic kids, disabled kids, fat kids and nerds and Goths and plain old weird kids who don’t fit in — that their very existence is too upsetting for normal kids to see, and they should crawl back under their rocks.

I don’t really have much to say about this.  Perhaps O’Hehir is right–the “R” content, so considered by the MPAA, is actually the “bullied” person and not any violence or “offensive” language.

O’Hehir makes an important point too about bureaucratic paralysis: as Lenin asked, What can be done–and by whom?  We are not a level nation but a leveled one.  At any moment a superior might bully you too.  Bureaucracy intends to always be irresponsible in its lack of clear responsibility: the buck–natch–stops nowhere.  But hidden here as well is the desperate desire to be hidden, to insulate one’s own living from the bully culture.

Further we might imagine that there is nothing here to see unless it is that this movie is simply about America; bullying is our stock in trade.

What is a consumer economy but a bully economy?  Walk into any store housing goods of at best questionable value and use (and even provenance) and you are immediately accosted by the aggression of marketplace coercion.

What is a corporation (or nation) but hierarchical orders beholden to the absolute authority of its fiduciary alpha who will brook no blown whistles?

What is military power but the power of the bully?  What power is the greatest bully the world has ever known?  The USA.  It is our true exceptionalism.  This nation’s leaders and its people have proven time and again that it is willing to murder and ignore any and all laws–its own and any it “supports” in the international community.

I’m sure many among you will be able to argue that the school itself offers an abiding model for the bullying culture.  Principals are often not your “pal” and teachers can be a kid’s worst nightmare and this is not to mention the sheer overwhelming nature of our large school systems that teach, by size alone, the insignificance of the weak and poor as they hug hallway walls and keep their heads down; that the athletic systems and “high ability” systems mimic the class systems themselves.  Those who eat well and sleep well and live safely and in comfort will obviously be dominant and will dominate.

Who can even be moved by a film showing the status quo living of this America?  “Deal with it!” is our only wisdom.

Inherent in the fabric of our daily living is the soul of the worst person you have ever met.

More than likely he stands in front of your mirror.

[See also the recent review of the new movie “Detachment,” Henry, A Portrait of Disinterest.]

photo credit: trix0r’s photostream

Tags: , , , , , , , , , ,

Douglas Storm is a host and producer for Interchange on Bloomington, Indiana's community radio station WFHB. "Why then do you try to 'enlarge' your mind? Subtilize it..."

One Response to “The Unexceptional, Unsurprising Success of America’s Bully Class” Subscribe

  1. Bobby V March 30, 2012 at 1:27 pm #

    Much of American culture is based on dominance. I would like to say that this especially true for contemporary American culture, but I don’t really believe it. I just wrote and deleted two different paragraphs trying to contrast contemporary qualities of dominance with historical qualities. I can’t do it; in the end it just seems the same. Maybe in the past a veneer of etiquette and civility made dominance and submission look a bit different. Self control is one of those passe virtues that Americans have pretty much dispensed with – believe me, I attended a middle school band performance last night and the behavior of a large portion of both children and adults in the audience was amazing. I think maybe in situations where people depend on smaller social groups – whether that’s small towns, neighborhoods, trade associations, or whatever – they are freer to be less self absorbed. Interesting to consider that the elevation of the self does not produce greater freedom.

    You’ve probably already seen the following BBC documentary, but if you haven’t, I HIGHLY recommend it:

    “The Century of the Self”

Leave a Reply

Glorifying War Shall Not Grow Old

Concerning War Movies (prompted by a conversation about Peter Jackson’s movie They Shall Not Grow Old). In J. D. Salinger’s […]

Cutting Down the Clouds

This winter they are cutting down our woods more seriously than ever,—Fair Haven Hill, Walden, Linnaea Borealis Wood, etc. etc. […]

Representative Texts from Hawthorne to Dickinson

In your daily busyness you are pressed for time to think and often choose instead anesthetization – watching any number […]

Between Hope and Defeat, History and Heaven

“God himself culminates in the present moment.” (Thoreau) What is “now” for? What if you “know” the future? Fairy tales […]

Absolute Solutions Necessary

Only two things to do: 1. zero out carbon emissions 2. exception: all technological and scientific labor exploring new solutions […]

Rachel Carson’s book had no real effect

Facing Global Climate Disruption and the End of Everything All At Once… David Wallace-Wells’ The Uninhabitable Earth tries very hard […]