A teacher in any institution ONLY needs tenure if he/she plans to teach an antagonistic stance to the institution.

A teacher does not need to TEACH the national economic structure; does not need to teach the use of primary technologies used in that structure.  These are de facto our “ground” of political, economic and social thinking.

A teacher, in teaching a kind of antagonistic pragmatism, should study the ways and means of these “ideas” in order to “de-idealize” them and at the very least offer to the students the ways to make use of them.  To that end the teacher must teach AGAINST these ideals in order to logically show the student how best to BE the manipulator of them so that the student may stand on equal footing with the powers in society and government.

We should not learn how to use technology but rather learn how to do without technology.  We should not learn capitalism but learn how to do without it.


Here is Burke again, from Counter-Statment (1931), offering a summary of our “universal patterns” in social history and the “channelizing of potentialities” (48-9):

“The researches of anthropologists indicate that man has “progressed” in cultural cycles which repeat themselves in essence (in form) despite the limitless variety of specific details to embody such essences, or forms.  Speech, material traits (for instance, tools), art, mythology, religion, social systems, property, government, and war–these are the nine “potentials” which man continually re-individuates into specific cultural channels, and which anthropologists call the “universal pattern.”  And when we speak of psychological universals, we mean simply that just as there is inborn in the germ-plasm of a dog the potentiality of barking, so ther is inborn in the germ-plasm of man the potentiality of speech, art, mythology, and so on.  And while these potentialities are continually changing their external aspects, their “individuations,” they do not change in essence.

“Given the potentiality for speech, the child of any culture will speak the language which it hears.  There is not mental equipment for speaking Chinese which is different from the mental equipment for speaking English.  But the potentiality externalizes itself in accordance with the traditions into which the individual happens to be born.  And by education we do not mean the “awakening” of a moral, or religious, or social, or artistic sense, but he leading of such potentialities into one specific channel.  We cannot teach the moral sense any more than we can teach abstract thought to a dog.  But we can individuate the moral sense by directing it into a specific code or tradition.  The socialists today imply this fact when they object to the standard bourgeois education, meaning that in channelizes the potentialities  of the child into a code which protects the bourgeois interests, whereas they would have these same potentialities differently individuated to favor the proletarian revolution.”*


Tenure is unnecessary and, as the corporate profiteers assert, unnecessarily costly, if our teachers do not attempt to present competing “channels” through which a student might individuate sense, moral, social, artistic, or religious.

*no paragraph break in original

Tags: , , , , , , , ,

Douglas Storm is a host and producer for Interchange on Bloomington, Indiana's community radio station WFHB. "Why then do you try to 'enlarge' your mind? Subtilize it..."

No comments yet.

Leave a Reply

Glorifying War Shall Not Grow Old

Concerning War Movies (prompted by a conversation about Peter Jackson’s movie They Shall Not Grow Old). In J. D. Salinger’s […]

Cutting Down the Clouds

This winter they are cutting down our woods more seriously than ever,—Fair Haven Hill, Walden, Linnaea Borealis Wood, etc. etc. […]

Representative Texts from Hawthorne to Dickinson

In your daily busyness you are pressed for time to think and often choose instead anesthetization – watching any number […]

Between Hope and Defeat, History and Heaven

“God himself culminates in the present moment.” (Thoreau) What is “now” for? What if you “know” the future? Fairy tales […]

Absolute Solutions Necessary

Only two things to do: 1. zero out carbon emissions 2. exception: all technological and scientific labor exploring new solutions […]

Rachel Carson’s book had no real effect

Facing Global Climate Disruption and the End of Everything All At Once… David Wallace-Wells’ The Uninhabitable Earth tries very hard […]